Geoffrey are murdered during the a riding accident during the 1186 and Constance married (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, 4 th Earl regarding Chester, towards the step three rd February 1188, in the a married relationship create by King Henry 11. This relationships deteriorated and you can Ranulph imprisoned Constance in the 1196. Rebellions was indeed stimulated all over Brittany on the and you can Ranulph put-out their into the 1198. Back in Brittany, Constance got her matrimony annulled and soon after in the 1198, she got People de Tours just like the their ‘second’ partner.
Constance died old forty, (possibly out-of leprosy, maybe following childbirth to help you dual girls) on the 5 th Sep 1201 from the Nantes
Although this wasn’t good consanguineous relationship but certainly attraction, any first-education relationships could have made relationship anywhere between Constance and any of John’s brothers impossible without a good dispensation –– and that given the party’s rank might have had to come from the newest pope themselves
The concept you to definitely Constance got an affair having John adopting the death of Geoffrey and you can in advance of John’s wedding so you’re able to Isabella away from Gloucester inside the 1189, and this she was mom so you’re able to Joanna is extremely controversial and you can keeps provoked much discussion in this genealogical groups.
One remark away from a great genealogist says one to ‘the fresh log ‘This new Plantagenet Connection’ has blogged a keen ahnentafel from Age Plantagenet, wife of Henry V11, which provides Joanna’s mother’s identity as the Constance (possibly misnamed Clemence?), Duchess regarding Brittany. Here is the Constance who was John’s brother-in-legislation! As a result of the really-known animosity anywhere between John and Constance along with her individual tries to push her child Arthur’s passion in terms of brand new throne of The united kingdomt are worried (and we every know the way disastrously one to turned-out!), I must say i discover the advised relationships a tiny tough to ingest. The latest Constance you to background portrays will not strike me personally due to the fact on the exactly who John could easily coerce on the sleep.’
‘ A theory who choose Joanna’s mother as Constance does not make up a highly vital point in canon rules. Who would indicate that particular shade of one’s count need certainly have come down to you, when it with it the newest request for it, the new deliberations, or the real dispensation alone. As much as i am aware, nothing of your form is present.’
From the just having sex that have John, let-alone results him an infant, Constance might have dependent a first-studies relationships of affinity with John’s siblings –– including John’s aunt Geoffrey
My own personal viewpoint for just what it is worth, is the fact had Constance already been the mother from Joanna she would definitely features brought their particular up in her family and her title would-be also also known as Constance’s other students by the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Fair Maid out of Brittany, Matilda/Maud away from Brittany and you may Arthur).
Agatha was born regarding the 1168 inside the Chartley Castle, Staffordshire. It is well known one she are a domme out-of John and several family relations trees render their, in the event solitary, because mom out-of Joanna. Most genealogists not are of the opinion that it is just supposition you to she actually is Joanna’s mom as the zero proof otherwise facts exist showing that it.
One resource appear to provided try Sir William Dugdale, on the Baronage out of The united kingdomt (1675-6). He states their supply to get Dr David Howell’s ‘History of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s tasks are an enlarged release of H Lloyd’s interpretation from ‘This new https://brightwomen.net/no/russiske-kvinner/ Historie from Cambria’ because of the several th century Saint Caradoc out-of Llancarfan. Another resource, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ of the Charles Browning, copyright 1969 and additionally names Agatha de Ferrers, daughter off Robert de Ferrers, 4th Earl regarding derby, once the Joanna’s mother.
Whether or not she cannot be completely overlooked due to the fact a candidate having mother regarding Joanna, positively there would be specific shade off their unique when you look at the a beneficial chronicle or other historic reference, in the event the she got in fact started the caretaker of the wife out of the newest Prince off Northern Wales.